John Browning vs. The Tupperware Party. Or the 1911 vs. the Glock

John Browning vs. The Tupperware Party.  Or the 1911 vs. the Glock

I’ll be honest, I’m sick of it.  I grow increasingly weary at the back and forth debate between pistol shooters.  Nay, I grow weary of the back and forth between those who worship the handgun and poo-poo the rifle. This debate is of course between two contending giants, well small giants, we’ll say giant midgets. In one corner, the “Steel and Wood” masterpiece sent down from heaven above and gifted to us by way of John Browning in the form of the US M1911 service pistol.  The other, by way of Gaston Glock and all those who copied, er, improved on his design.

The debate has only grown fiercer in recent years as it seems every company that makes boom sticks has jumped on the polymer train and introduced an inexpensive combat pistol of their own. What was once the talk of Tupperware ladies everywhere, polymer, has now taken handgun owners by storm.

So which is better?

I know that’s what you are thinking, “C’mon dude, what is your opinion?”

I choose the Glock. I own several polymer guns. But to me, they are a marginally useful piece of defensive equipment. If given a choice, I’ll take a rifle over either of them any day of the week.

We live in a world where we have become so enamored by what we can carry on our hips we ignore one of the basic truths that has emerged over the past decades, backed up by real science.  Not the polar ice cap melting “science”. Handgun Stopping Power is a Myth.  The old “one shot drop” from a .45?  Myth.  Unless you are shooting a magnum handgun cartridge such as a .44 or a 10mm, all you are doing is putting small, underpowered holes in a bad guy.  The idea that you can hit a man in the pinky with a .45 and spin him around and make him drop with one shot is completely unhinged. 

You have more of a chance of capturing and breeding Loch Ness monsters. 

So who wins the great 1911 vs the Glock debate? Neither.  None. 

Yes, a pistol will kill.  But with a handgun, shot placement and the ability to put more than one rounds in a target quickly is what will win the day. 

A pistol is what you carry when you can’t carry a rifle.  Ideally, a pistol should be a tool to get you to a rifle. 

A pistol is a tool.  The rifle is the superior tool. 

If you are going to pack heat downtown, get a handgun you can shoot well. If you are going to buy a home defense firearm, get a rifle.  If you are going to be an internet hero, get a $2,000 Browning designed piece with a custom trigger.  That’s just the reality of the situation on the ground.


Submit a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You may also like...

Preparing For A Disaster

I used to not want to admit it, but we live in an unstable world, and it is getting more dangerous as the days go by. I believe that preparing our families for what lies ahead is amongst the most critically important things that we can do.

The Farmall Super A

The Farmall Super A was itself a successor to the popular Farmall A, and entered production in 1947. Over 107,000 Super A rolled off of International Harvester’s Farmall production lines between 1947 and 1954.

Democrats Pass Gun Control Bill in House

The Democrat Controlled House of Representatives took further steps today to infringe upon your God-given rights and Liberty.  In a Bill the will require mandatory background checks on all but private sales between relatives, the Left is pushing hard for a defacto Universal Gun Registry. 

Making Hay with Old Iron

For the new farmer, older equipment is often the only choice when outfitting your farm for a haying operation. Be wise and choose equipment carefully.

About The Author

Zach Dunn

Zach Dunn is one of the owners of 1776TV and serves as Senior Editor. He is a passionate Constitutionalist. He enjoys the Outdoors, Firearms, and History. He is a passionate follower of Jesus Christ. Zach is married to Amy and they have a son and three daughters. He currently resides in the Mountains of North Carolina.